What Is Protein Powder?
What Is Pre-workout?
Pre Workout vs Protein Powder
Processing of Protein Powder vs Pre Workout
Depending on the raw materials used for the production of protein powder, these products are of animal or plant origin. The most popular protein powders of animal origin are whey and casein. For example, whey protein is obtained in the process of cheese making by adding enzymes to milk that separate whey from the casein part. Next, the whey goes through the processes of filtration and drying to form a powder.
For the production of plant based protein powders, the initial raw materials are cleaned of the outer shell, grounded into a fine flour, and under the action of enzymes, the protein part is separated from the starch. Depending on the specific source (hemp, pea, rice), production methods differ. However, in the final result we get a powder form of plant-based protein.
For the production of pre-workouts, powder forms of individual ingredients, which are produced from different substrates, are mixed into one product. For example, caffeine can be produced either by extraction from natural sources (for example, from kola nut, cacao bean or guarana berries), or by chemical synthesis from urea and chloroacetic acid (however there is no chemical difference between synthetic and naturally sourced caffeine). All the necessary components of pre-workout can be blended in needed amounts to create the required formula. Additionally, most pre-workout supplements have fruit-based flavors, which are added using various natural and artificial ingredients.
So, is pre workout the same as protein powder? If you were looking for an answer to this question, now you know for sure that these are completely different types of supplements.
Average Macros per Serving
Generally, protein powders contain 20-25 grams of protein (although vegan powders often contain 15-20 g), with 0-5 grams of fat, 0-10 grams of carbs (vegan versions usually contain closer to the upper range), and 100-160 calories per serving.
Pre-workouts are fat-free, most are carb-free, although some may have a few grams of carbohydrates. Does pre workout have protein? No, but it may contain amino acids, such as BCAA or tyrosine, which still have calories.
In general, pre-workouts are not the type of supplement that contains a significant amount of calories per serving. However, if you are in the final stage of cutting and meticulously counting every calorie, you should still consider the calories you can get from pre-workouts that contain a few grams of carbohydrates and amino acids.
Each serving of protein powder will cost $1-2, with the price going up or down depending on the source (vegan or animal-based), type of protein (concentrate or isolate), and specific brand. For example, whey protein isolates are more expensive than whey protein concentrate due to additional filtration steps and a higher percentage of protein in relation to the total caloric content per serving.
That said, there are plenty of great-tasting and reasonably-priced options out there if you take the time to shop around.
Depending on the brand that you choose, the overall ingredients breakdown, dosing of each ingredient and availability of third-party certification, the price per serving can range from as little as $0.6 to $2.5.
Protein vs. Pre-workout: Summary
Both supplements have different purposes and are therefore not interchangeable, so there really shouldn’t be a debate between pre workout and protein powder. In fact, you can use both supplements at the same time, although this requires further explanation.
In general, protein powders can be used by almost anyone, at any time of the day. What can not be said about pre-workouts. This type of supplement should be used by people with regular training experience, good caffeine metabolism, and only before training (preferably in the first part of the day, if we talk about caffeinated products).
Also, most studies looking at pre-workouts lasted less than 8 weeks, so the long-term safety profile of this type of supplement is still unknown. For this reason, it is better to follow the path of minimizing risks and take breaks when taking pre-workouts. On the other hand, protein powders can be used on a regular basis, especially if we're talking about products from reputable brands that submit their protein powders to third-party testing.
Pros and Cons of Pre-workout
Gives a stimulating effect and a boost of energy
Improves overall athletic performance and muscular endurance
Contribute to increasing strength, power output and lean muscle mass
Enhance the pumping effect of training if it contains certain ingredients in the right dosage
Increase alertness and mental focus
Could be better:
Not suitable for non-exercising individuals and beginners in training
Can cause negative side effects due to a large dose of caffeine
May cause a tingling sensation from a large single dose of beta-alanine (harmless, but uncomfortable feeling)
Has only been studied in short-term trials (long-term effects and safety still unknown)
Many pre-workouts contain a large number of additional ingredients that do not have scientific support, but add to the cost of the supplement
As a type of supplement pre-workouts contain more potential risks to consumers than protein powders
Pros and Cons of Protein Powder
Convenient way to increase the amount of protein in your diet
Saves time for preparing high-protein food
Helps build muscle mass and maintain it during cutting
Can be used at any time of the day and on a regular basis (without need to cycle) as a part of well-balanced diet
As a type of supplement have much better safety profile than pre-workouts
Could be better:
Does not have a stimulating effect (unlike a pre-workout)
Can be unpredictable in terms of gastrointestinal tolerance
Pre Workout vs. Protein Powder: When to Use Each
We’ve discussed the difference between pre workout and protein powder, and now we’ll go over when you should be using either supplement.
If you have been training regularly for a long period of time, have achieved results but stopped progressing and want to break through a training plateau, then you may want to try a pre-workout. They should be taken approximately 30-40 minutes before training.
However, consider your caffeine sensitivity and consult a doctor before buying your first pre-workout.
Protein powders can be used as an additional source of protein regardless of your training experience. If you want to add another serving of protein, or save time preparing a protein part of a meal, or have another option for a high-protein snack (for example, besides Greek yogurt), this is your choice! You can add protein powder to porridge or baked goods, and also use it in the form of a protein shake or smoothie.
Products We Recommend
The Bulk from Transparent Labs offers a simple, straightforward solution for taking your training sessions to the next level. Containing no nebulous proprietary blends, this pre-workout is a favorite of many athletes worldwide. And there are several reasons for this.
This product contains caffeine and other key ingredients such as citrulline malate, betaine, beta-alanine and several additional ingredients. The key ingredients are contained in dosages that have demonstrated effectiveness in trials (but be prepared for a tingle from a large dose of beta-alanine). You can count on an energy boost, better muscular endurance, increased pumping and better focus during your training sessions.
photo by @btl_fitness
The dose of caffeine is 200 mg per serving, which is enough to obtain the effects, while reducing the risk of side effects. And the presence of theanine can reduce anxiousness and jitters that you may experience from caffeine. Overall, BULK is great for experienced athletes who have already taken pre-workouts with a lower dose of caffeine. For those who have never taken this type of supplement before, it is best to look for a product with a lower dosage of caffeine.
Complete Vegan Protein Powder by PlantFusion contains 4 plant protein sources that complement and improve each other's amino acid profile. Each serving consists of 21 grams of protein and is also a good source of iron.
photo by @krystaloverall
This protein has gotten a lot of good reviews about the taste, which is a big factor for a plant-based protein. Overall, with a solid ingredient list and macros, this protein powder is an excellent choice for any athlete, vegan or not.
Does Pre-workout Have Protein?
No, this type of supplement does not contain protein, although many pre-workouts contain some amino acids (which are the building blocks of protein).
Is Pre-workout the Same as Protein Powder?
No, they are entirely different supplements with different purposes. Pre-workout gives you the energy boost and improves athletic performance during workouts, while protein powder helps cover daily protein needs.
To wrap up, both pre workout or protein powder can be useful supplements, although they serve different purposes. A pre-workout is a specialized sports supplement which is used only before training, while a protein powder is a convenience supplement, which is used at any time of the day and just helps cover the daily needs of protein.
Make sure to let me know which supplements you use in the comments!
- Natural vs. Added Caffeine: What’s the Difference? // Foodinsight: https://foodinsight.org/natural-vs-added-caffeine-whats-the-difference/
- Caffeine (1, 3, 7-trimethylxanthine) in Foods: A Comprehensive Review on Consumption, Functionality, Safety, and Regulatory Matters // Ift: https://ift.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1750-3841.2010.01561.x
- Energy content of diets of variable amino acid composition // Researchgate: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/20915822_Energy_content_of_diets_of_variable_amino_acid_composition
- Multi-ingredient pre-workout supplements, safety implications, and performance outcomes: a brief review // Jissn: https://jissn.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12970-018-0247-6#Sec39
Oleksandr is a professional fitness nutritionist, certified by FPA (Fitness Professional Association). Oleksandr adheres to the principles of evidence-based dietetics and instills in his clients a healthy relationship with food - without strict prohibitions on favorite foods and regular disruptions. His main task – not only get a result for you, but also maintain it for many years, enjoying tasty and delicious food.